Sadly, it can now be recorded as an historic fact that for the second consecutive general election in T&T, an attempt to host a leadership debate between the main political parties has failed.
It is sad that the two Leaders’ Debates, which were scheduled for last Wednesday and August 27, had to be cancelled by the T&T Debates Commission (TTDC).
Voters have been robbed of an opportunity to hear from the political leaders who want to take charge of this country’s affairs for the next five years and have been deprived of a very important measure by which they could have made informed decisions on the proposals put forward by the various contenders on the future development of T&T.
In truth, the death knell on this event was sounded a few weeks ago when attorney Larry Lalla, Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar’s liaison with the TTDC, raised concerns about bias on the part of the debate organisers. That was even before Mr Lalla’s farcical explanation that the Prime Minister would be too busy in August, or the gentle Q&A at CNMG, an encounter that Mrs Persad Bissessar's own media handlers would probably interpret as unchallenging.
The impasse that ensued could not be broken, even with appeals from various groups in the society who underscored the importance of such an event in the democratic process.
Sadly, it can now be recorded as an historic fact that for the second consecutive general election in T&T, an attempt to host a leadership debate between the main political parties has failed.
In May 2010, the debate had to be called off because the TTDC could not get all the political parties to participate.
This time around, while the ILP opted out early on, there had been initial agreement from the country’s two main political entities, the PP coalition and the PNM. However, things went awry during the course of negotiations to finalise arrangements.
After all is said and done, the biggest losers are the electorate. While there has been a flurry of campaign activities over the past several weeks, with an intensification since Nomination Day last Monday, most of these events have provided very little space for the burning questions prospective voters need to have answered. Public meetings and political rallies have become very tightly stage-managed affairs where the candidates and their teams control what is said and what information is released.
These events, in which droves of banner and flag-waving party supporters are bussed in to packed out venues are fun, but they’re not opportunities for the sober, careful assessment of political plans and ideologies that voters need to make.
It is painfully clear that the most important issues of the 2015 campaign are not being addressed in the paid political advertisements with which readers and viewers are being bombarded throughout the day.
The cancellation of the debate is, at the end of the day, a sad commentary on the immaturity of T&T’s democratic system.
However, it must not be allowed to detract from the TTDC’s efforts over the past five years. Voters should not forget that this autonomous, not for profit body established by the T&T Chamber of Industry & Commerce was able to host successful political debates ahead of the last Tobago House of Assembly and local government elections.
The fervent hope is that the interests of the electorate be given greater priority the next time there is an election in T&T, and that the leaders keep their promise to take part in a free and fair debate.